Quote:
Originally Posted by jpeters1734
I think your personality study has a slight flaw. You don't take into account the ratio of initial creation. Meaning, what percentage of players were created with a high WE? If 19% of all amateurs are created with a high WE and 10 years later 19% of those amateurs made the ML, you can conclude that high WE has no effect at all.
The question shouldn't be how many ML players are there with high WE. It should be, what percent of players created with high WE make the ML, and what percentage of players created with a low WE make it.
|
I think you've misunderstood his data. When he says, for example, "Intelligence: Very Low: 13.2%", he is saying that 13.2% of players with Very Low Intelligence made the Majors.