I would still argue there's an issue. Here's an example, as I'm on the same day in-game as the most recent scouting report. There is NO reason why the stars on the May 1st report shouldn't be exactly the same as the stars on the profile considering it is May 1st!
Notice in-game date and scouting report date are the same at 3.5 stars.
Notice in-game date and profile page date are the same at 4.5 stars.
