His ratings are good 4.5 stars, his stats were good. He has an awesome contract for what he offers. Ending with a team option year on his age 33 year. I have three other pitchers rated close to the same with comparable contracts. 1 of those guys was on the DL. It chose to keep two guys that were essentially half star to 1 star.
These forums have been very helpful. Scanning them for my issue prior to posting has yielded a great amount of tips and tricks that I will be putting to use.
Thank you to everyone that has weighed in on this.