Yeah I can see how a computer can differ from human minds. Which is really cool by the way, it's awesome to see how a computer would rate a player and how I would, it's very interesting.
McCann is also one of the better pitch framers in the game, so it's odd he dropped. Didn't know that 93-95 meant hitting 97 or 98 sometimes, thanks for the info!
As for Tanaka, he's definitely an ace in the game so it's not a huge deal. Just me being nitpicky and wanting everything to be right, but obviously that would be too much work.
Also since defensive projecting/stats tend to be weird and aren't exactly the best right now, Trout is only a 55 is CF on the 20-80 and 69 on the 1-100. I know the stats don't love him, but I think we can all agree he's at the very least well above-average defensively in CF. At least 65+. Same with Ellsbury. Again the stats seem to hate him bigtime, so he's only a 55 I believe. He should also be 65+ in my eyes. Lastly, Miguel Cabrera is 88 defensively at 1B, way too overrated.
Yeah, Miller had major issues with walks in his career, but got much better the past 2. Might just be a career year type of thing, but you could definitely give him a good rating because of last year.
Thanks for the replies and fixes, hope I've helped in my own annoying ways!
Forgot to ask: When you make these tweaks, how do I get them? And if I begin a new game I assume I won't be able to have the tweaks later, correct?