Quote:
Originally Posted by JeffR
The problem is, though, that any ratings system is going to have big flaws - if I draw one up, it wouldn't have the same problems the EHM system does, but I guarantee it's going to have some. Hockey's very difficult to measure in that way, and you also have to account for the player's role - if Colton Orr plays five minutes with no shots or points and fights twice, that's a pretty good game for him. If Phil Kessel does that, it's terrible.
|
and judging a players performance on stats alone has exactly the same problems. im not picky in how its done really, but some indication of how a player is playing would be useful.
you mentioned the fm asst coach feedback as an option, which id be totally ok with.