Two pitchers, similar ratings - one rated 1 star potential, the other 2.5 potential.
Take a look.
Pitcher A potential- Stuff 4, Movement 7, Control 6, Stamina 9, hold 8, g/f .57
Pitcher B potential- Stuff 4, Movement 7, Control 6, Stamina 9, hold 6, g/f .46
Pitcher A identical ratings, advantage in hold runners. Overall ratings 1 star, getting rocked in AAA (1-2, 5.65 ERA)
Pitcher B same ratings, a bit less at holding runners. Overall rating 2.5, dominating majors (10-5, 3.67)
The reason I'm asking this is because I made up a spreadsheet where I insert component ratings and get a score. This will be used in free agency to decide who to pursue. That plan can go out the window with these results.
Player A link:
Player Report for #43 Dennis Rasmussen
Player B link:
Player Report for #32 Jaime Navarro
Your thoughts?
Thanks