Mark. It's been a while since I've rated a fighter but Edgar "Mad Dog" Ross had a very interesting record. Almost all of his fights were in Orlando, Florida and his record of 57(41)-2(1)-2 looked really good until you examined the records of his opponents. Tony Chiaverini was the best of a pretty nondescript crew of opponents. The challenge of rating him for me was how you evaluate a hometown favorite with an impressive record whose only stoppage defeat came in his last fight at age 30 against a better caliber fighter. He reminded me somewhat of Lamar Clark - great KO record against dead bodies before meeting a young Cassius Clay (Ali) - only Ross' opponents had better records and he carried the fight against his best opponent into the last round. Using Clark's ratings as a very general template to work from, here is what I came up with for him without much testing or tweaking.
Ross_Edgar.tbdx3