[Puckett guy]

To my knowledge OSA has never been 100% accurate. In fact normally a decent scout will give you more accurate information than will OSA. Here is a quote from the original OOTP 14 newsletter:

"We have recoded the way OOTP evaluates players, both for the OSA and your head scout. For example, players with several years of pro experience are now better scouted than in previous versions, and the OSA is more accurate overall, providing a valid second opinion on players. There are also players who are vastly overrated or underrated by almost all scouts, resulting in more late-round surprises."