OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post

Eugene Church · 06-24-2003, 12:22 AM

Cuss16,

You are really remarkable, skilled and very creative in logo designing.

So don't let my opinion hurt your feelings...it is meant only to offer an observation and an evalution of this logo, which you requested.

I like logos that are not cluttered and busy.

This one is done beautifully with great graphic skills and creativity...but it's hard for me see what it is.

I think your designs get too complicated.

I wish you wouldn't cover up part of the lettering.

Let the entire nickname be visible.

Take my opinion with a grain of salt. I'm not the MTV generation.
I'm old-fashioned, traditional... and old, too.

I hope you will still do my logo project as this critique is meant only to give you some feedback to perhaps improve your work.

To improve one needs to have criticism, hopefully from someone who knows what he is talking about...which may not be true in my case. I was a country disc jockey for 32 years and and getting negative critiques hurt...but in general, the negative ones are what make me a better announcer.

I know a good logo when I see one...and a good one is one that is done the way I like them. Beauty is in the eye of the Beholder.

But I can still see your great skill even when I may not be fond of that particular design.

06-24-2003, 12:22 AM	#5
Eugene Church Hall Of Famer Join Date: Aug 2002 Posts: 36,205	Cuss16, You are really remarkable, skilled and very creative in logo designing. So don't let my opinion hurt your feelings...it is meant only to offer an observation and an evalution of this logo, which you requested. I like logos that are not cluttered and busy. This one is done beautifully with great graphic skills and creativity...but it's hard for me see what it is. I think your designs get too complicated. I wish you wouldn't cover up part of the lettering. Let the entire nickname be visible. Take my opinion with a grain of salt. I'm not the MTV generation. I'm old-fashioned, traditional... and old, too. I hope you will still do my logo project as this critique is meant only to give you some feedback to perhaps improve your work. To improve one needs to have criticism, hopefully from someone who knows what he is talking about...which may not be true in my case. I was a country disc jockey for 32 years and and getting negative critiques hurt...but in general, the negative ones are what make me a better announcer. I know a good logo when I see one...and a good one is one that is done the way I like them. Beauty is in the eye of the Beholder. But I can still see your great skill even when I may not be fond of that particular design.