Here's another pinch hitting example. The last I could find. This is from the only historical season I've ever played, managing the '25 Giants in v10.
Here you can see my PH actually performed extremely well. Go figure. All the 'negative' examples I gave are from v11 and v12 using the MLB quickstart. I'm not trying to find data just to back up my claim. The data I gave is all I could find. Sure, it could happen once, but three times? (Actually 7 times as mentioned before, but I don't have the data to back that up.)
I'm not trying to to be a

ssh

le here. I'm new on these boards, but I'm not a new user complaining after a handful of games played. I've played this game since v10, and over the last two versions I have played out 7 seasons each time with simmilar results. It seems to me I just found a problem, which is backed up by the data provided.
Now, if this is the case then there must be other users experiencing the same. If so feel free to add to this thread and provide simmilar data. If you play the game the same way I do as mentioned in the original post and have completely different results, also feel free to provide data.
Well, look at me, I'm rambling again. I guess sometimes you eat OOTP and sometimes OOTP, well, eats you.