Quote:
Originally Posted by Chicagofan76
Jeter, as great as he is better not even be in the top 5 maybe not even in top 10 for All Time Yankees. Ruth, Dimaggio, Mantle, Gehrig, Berra, Ford r the top 6, heck I would even put Billy Martin & Casey Stengel in front of Jeter. Jeter at 9 and Mattingly at 10.
|
You need a top eight of tier one players. Bill Dickey and the dreaded closer the White Sox can't touch as my only contemporary pick . Jeter and about four score and seven other guys make it into the next tier. Lets See: Meusel, Combs, Lazzeri, Hoyt, Pennock, Heinrich, Keller, Gordon, Rizzuto, Bauer, Slowron, Boyer, Rolfe, McDougald, Maris, Howard, Jeter, Nettles, Munson, et, al.