The way I look at it is that it was for your top 25 all time favorite players - which is pretty hard - at least for me and everybody on my list really was a favorite of mine.
Basically, I put together a team out of my favorite players. No offense to role players, but I like Ryan Theriot and would be considered a favorite, but between him and Nomar - I'm taking Nomar (also liked him more anyways but hopefully you see my point).
Maybe an idea is to build a team out of your favorites but cap the HOF or probably HOFs (like Griffey) ofcourse then we'll be arguing someone credentials. Hmmmm, I see a project
