FWIW, I had a White Sox dynasty that I started in OOTP5 using a user-created MLB roster set that (can't remember who made it, but it was
the roster set for 5), and Buehrle wound up winning 324 games and multiple Cy Young awards. In 2005 in that dynasty, he set a modern-day MLB record by winning his first 20 decisions.
So...yeah, I liked that better.