@Jestor - That totally slipped my mind.
Guess I was more preoccupied with the fact that my 2015 draft featured an outfielder named Jake Roberts, plus the fictional Mwambetumba whom I created for the 2014 class. (He got drafted by an AL team, so I guess we won't see yet his potential as a pitcher who can hit.) Anyway, James isn't my rookie, so I'll be revisiting his stats once the 2019 season's done.
Going back to the dynasty and revisiting the 2010 Top 10 amateur draftees...
10/22/2015 - Washington edges Atlanta 4-3, wins NL pennant and sets up World Series rematch with Seattle Mariners!
6. NEW YORK METS - Dustin "The Phantom" Dawson (SP)
With UCSB - 8-3, 29 BB, 119 K (103.1 IP)
Dawson was one of the first rookies in the pitcher-friendly, highly-successful 2010 draft class to see major league action. After just a little over 38 minor league innings, Dawson hit the majors in 2011 and impressed observers with his fielding skills, eventually winning the 2012 Gold Glove for NL pitchers. He enjoyed his best season in 2014, where he went 16-8, posting a 3.08 ERA and striking out 146 batters in 216 innings. He has been very consistent since 2012, though - his ERA hasn't gone over 4.00 since his rookie season.
7. ARIZONA - Anthony Ranaudo (SP)
With LSU - N/A (real-life player)
Ranaudo has been in the majors for four complete seasons, but has yet to post a winning record as a starting pitcher. Still, this may be more indicative of his subpar supporting cast with the Diamondbacks, er...Sinks. While capable of fanning close to eight batters per 9 innings, his control has been a bit iffy these past two years. His major league stats to date - 38-57, 4.65 ERA, 292 BB and 613 K in 775.2 innings.
8. HOUSTON - Jesus Ruiz (SP)
With St. John's - 10-2, 2.47 ERA, 29 BB, 125 K (120.1 IP)
Like Dawson, Ruiz made a comparatively early Major League debut, suiting up midway in the 2011 for the Astros after starting the year in single A. And while his stuff is oftentimes nasty, what with his 96 mph fastball, he seems to alternate great years (i.e. 2014 - 16-4, 2.94 ERA, 61 BB and 149 K in 220.1 IP) with not-so-great years (i.e. 2013 - 6-16, 4.71 ERA, 60 BB, 127 K in 200.2 IP). His 2015 season was somewhere in between those numbers, so judging by the looks of things, he seems to be finding a comfort zone with the Astros.
9. TORONTO - Deck McGuire (SP)
With Georgia Tech - N/A (real-life player)
McGuire may have been known in the minors as a strikeout machine (53 K in just 35.1 IP with Short Season A Auburn in 2011), but he's been known in the majors as a pitcher with solid, but unspectacular stuff but nevertheless able to get the job done. After struggling with giving up hits and a 5.22 ERA in 2014, McGuire started off strongly in 2015 and eventually made his first All-Star Game. His 2015 season-ending stats were his best-ever - 16-11, 68 BB, 142 K in 211.1 IP.
10. SAN DIEGO - Karsten Whitson (SP)
With Chipley HS - N/A (real-life player)
Unlike fellow high school pitcher and Top 10 pick Jameson Taillon, Whitson hasn't done quite a good job of dealing with his control issues. He's had his share of phenomenal rookie league years, such as a 2013 Single A season where he went 9-5 with a 2.69 ERA and 144 strikeouts in 130 innings, but his control has mostly been spotty, and as he made his major league debut in 2015, he was asked to do mostly middle relief duty. Not a good sign for someone drafted in the Top 10 as a starting pitcher. Whitson pitched 63.2 innings in 43 games (5 starts), and while he retired 66 batters, he gave 45 others free passes. The jury is still out, but keep a close eye on his wild pitching.
Top 10 All-Stars - 4
Top 10 Busts - NONE YET