http://www.ootpdevelopments.com/boar...e-pitcher.html
"I have a pitcher in my starting rotation and no matter where I put him (starting in the majors, bullpen in the majors, starting in the minors, etc.) the AI will not use him. If it is his turn in the rotation and everyone else is tired, the AI will start one of my middle relievers. The only game he's pitched this year was a game I played out where I had to insert him into the rotation. It was his spot, but the lineup screen came up with no pitcher selected prior to the game."
Im having the same issue, and the pitcher, both Clay Bucholtz and John Smoltz have more then 3 pitches, i dont know what is causing this problem