I think we can all agree that trading is definitly something that's a matter of opinion. I really like the new interface, in fact, we're almost to my favorite trading interface: Front Page Sports series where you select a player, hit a button and a list of players the other teams would trade for that particular player came up. This is close, but you have to click on every team to 'shop' the player.
That being said, the trading seems really messed up and I think it has to do with the AI evaluating stats more than ratings now, which is good for vets, but not rookies. Hopefully Markus can tighten this up a bit.
I'm not going to 'evaluate' every trade to see if it was fair or not, I don't have the time and that's not why I bought the game. Maybe I'm wrong here, only time will tell.
I'll evaluate my recent trade later on in the year, he's on my player tracker!
Todd