OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post

Curtis · 09-01-2008, 07:58 PM

Thank you for the reply, Nutlaw. I have to say that this qualifies as a major disappointment. I'll quote something I posted in a thread in General Discussions:

"I haven't tried that yet {changing to rating vs. all players}, but I don't like the idea. How can you compare a shortstop to a starting pitcher? What if the game engine values apples higher, while I value oranges higher? And to top it off, if the game engine DOES value apples higher, I'll never know!"

Rating vs. other players at same position seems to me to be the logical way of doing things, and it seems like it should be the default. If this complaint isn't going to get a tracking number, then you might as well close it. This is a BAD design decision.

09-01-2008, 07:58 PM	#5
Curtis Hall Of Famer Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Watertown, New York Posts: 4,567	Thank you for the reply, Nutlaw. I have to say that this qualifies as a major disappointment. I'll quote something I posted in a thread in General Discussions: "I haven't tried that yet {changing to rating vs. all players}, but I don't like the idea. How can you compare a shortstop to a starting pitcher? What if the game engine values apples higher, while I value oranges higher? And to top it off, if the game engine DOES value apples higher, I'll never know!" Rating vs. other players at same position seems to me to be the logical way of doing things, and it seems like it should be the default. If this complaint isn't going to get a tracking number, then you might as well close it. This is a BAD design decision.