Quote:
Originally posted by NYJuggalo45
some other questions, checking out league wide ratings:
1. Elmer Dessens is a 3/4 after a 3era season last year
2. Marcus Giles and Wilson Betemit talent ratings too high
3. Chipper Jones HR rating too low
4. Geronimo Gil is known as a defensive catcher with pop, but u have a D range/arm for him
5. Derek Lowe still seems off to me, 6/6
6. Bartolo Colon seems low
7. Tom Gordon's injury rating needs to be Prone not normal
8. Jimmy Haynes, 15-10, last year, is rated so low shouldn't even be on the major league team
9. Have Wohlers listed as Closer and Wickman and Riske listed as MR
10. Matt Anderson listed as MR not Closer
11. Pretty sure Biggio is going to play CF this year and Berkman will move to LF, you didn't give Biggion a CF rating
12. Mike Macdougal is going to be KC's opening day CL, you have him in AA with a 0 era rating
13. Johan Santana seems very low, this guy will be great
14. Tony Armas has better ratings than Tom Glavine, way too good
15. Brad Wilkerson is NOT a 5 star prospect
16. Contreras, a guy who has never pitched in the majors and been shelled in spring, is the Yankees highest rated SP
17. Rick Harden looks like he might win the A's #5 SP spot but you have in AA nowhere near MLB level in development
18. Joe Valentine is not ready for the majors, needs his ratings lowered but talent remain
19. Chavez and Tejada hit same HR's last year, but Chavez is a 10, Tejada is a 7
20. Josh Fogg is rated too low
21. Jesse Foppert shouldn't be at AAA level ratings, AA more like it
22. Ichiro only a 7 in hits?
23. Matt Morris seems too low, back to back great seasons
24. Brazelton a 0 in ERA but will make the opening day roster
25. Nick Bierbrodt, despite taking a bullet, is no where to be found on TB's roster
26. Urbina listed as MR not closer
27. Halladay is a future Cy Young winner, yet you have him maxed at 6/6
|
A couple of these so GForce doesn't really have to....(Note I Haven't looked much into the ratings, but some of the basic questions I can answer by reading what GForce wrote)
5. Derek Lowe did have a very good year, but you remember it is more then just the last year that was taken into effect. And the runs allowed is based on all other ratings.
9. Danys Baez is going to be the Closer for Cleveland
12. While MacDougal should be given some sort of a rating, lol just because he's going to be KC's Closer doesn't mean he's good.
16. Contreras is considered by many by far the best pitcher to ever come out of Cuba, and seems to have settled down and has pitched well his last one or two times out. Story on espn.com about it. Shouldn't be the best on the staff, but then again if you think about the Yankees staff isn't all that GREAT, it's just got a lot of good starters.
21. Foppert is going to start the year in Triple-A
22. Ichiro didn't have a great season last year compared to his first. 7 is still very good.
24. Brazelton should be given something, but he's not going to make the opening day rotation, he's going to start in Triple-A barring a late ST injury to one of the 5 starters.
Just a couple note sso GForce doesn't have to.