[Erik W.]

I don't think Young Tyson is overrated at all. In fact, I think Young Tyson is underrated in retrospect. Few people seem to remember just how good his defense was. He wasn't just a puncher by any means. Of course, he got derailed in what should have been his prime, so we'll never know what could've been.

Leonard is certainly overrated. I also think Gatti is highly overrated by the public at large. People seem to think he's a great fighter, when he's just a human punching bag who got famous by fighting another human punching bag. Tough as heck, sure, but not a great boxer. Although I don't know if Gatti belongs on the list on this board since you folks seem to be more into the sport than the lemmings who think Gatti is good.