OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post - BUG (2.0.2.50) - Trade AI - Can easily rip off computer teams (Was closed

dim13 · 05-09-2007, 08:56 PM

Here's an example with player with much higher ratings involved:

(CF) Marlon Sicho - (49-67-76-61-45) Potential: (47-68-73-58-44) (4/4 stars)

(MR) Peter Mencl - (66-80-41) Potential: (64-82-42) (4/4 stars)
(SP) Hung Cathey - (54-29-48) Potential: (55-30-49) (1/1 star)

To simulate - I uploaded my data files:
- ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save...w/dim13New.zip

Supporting screenshots:
- ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/1New.JPG
- ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/2New.JPG
- ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/3aNew.JPG
- ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/4New.JPG
- ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/5New.JPG

(UserName: ftp-public, Password: public)

- I am managing the 'Jasper Dragsters' (Level 1 League)
- I trade with the 'Renfrew Continentals' (Level 1 League)
- everything else same as example above (Commissioner mode off, etc)

1) Offer (CF) Marlon Sicho for (MR) Peter Mencl - 'Complete Trade' button will be ghosted out.
- see: ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/1New.JPG
- If you hit 'Submit Offer' button - you'll get a 'NO WAY' email as a result.

2) Offer (CF) Marlon Sicho for (MR) Peter Mencl AND (SP) Hung Cathey- 'Complete Trade' button will be activated.
- see: ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/2New.JPG

Player Ratings (none are considered low):

(CF) Marlon Sicho
ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/3aNew.JPG

(MR) Peter Mencl
ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/4New.JPG

(SP) Hung Cathey
ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/5New.JPG

- Submitting (CF) Marlon Sicho for (MR) Peter Mencl straight up (without involving (SP) Hung Cathey) the trade was refused (got a 'NO WAY' email). But if I add (SP) Hung Cathey to the trade from the other team - the 'Complete Trade' button is activated and I can complete the trade.

- For players to acquire, If I had added (SP) Hung Cathey first in the list, and then added (MR) Peter Mencl second - the 'Complete Trade' button remains activated and I have absolutely no way off knowing that I am ripping off the computer team. I only can realize this if I had the players swapped - (MR) Peter Mencl first and then added (SP) Hung Cathey - for players to acquire from the other team.

- You can substitute the following players from the other team (in place of (MR) Peter Mencl), and repeat steps (1) and (2) above with the same flaw/results - this problem still exists:
- (SP) B.Iller
- (SS) I.Kectan
- (LF) S.Hug

Version: 2.0.2.50
PC/MAC: PC
Commissioner Mode: OFF

** I really hope Markus reads this example to let him know it's not just happening with players with very low ratings (as he stated). This example shows that it happens with all players, regardless of ratings. This is a major flaw that I really hope can be corrected at some point.

05-09-2007, 08:56 PM	#8
dim13 Major Leagues Join Date: Jan 2002 Location: tucson, az Posts: 344	Here's an example with player with much higher ratings involved: (CF) Marlon Sicho - (49-67-76-61-45) Potential: (47-68-73-58-44) (4/4 stars) (MR) Peter Mencl - (66-80-41) Potential: (64-82-42) (4/4 stars) (SP) Hung Cathey - (54-29-48) Potential: (55-30-49) (1/1 star) To simulate - I uploaded my data files: - ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save...w/dim13New.zip Supporting screenshots: - ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/1New.JPG - ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/2New.JPG - ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/3aNew.JPG - ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/4New.JPG - ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/5New.JPG (UserName: ftp-public, Password: public) - I am managing the 'Jasper Dragsters' (Level 1 League) - I trade with the 'Renfrew Continentals' (Level 1 League) - everything else same as example above (Commissioner mode off, etc) 1) Offer (CF) Marlon Sicho for (MR) Peter Mencl - 'Complete Trade' button will be ghosted out. - see: ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/1New.JPG - If you hit 'Submit Offer' button - you'll get a 'NO WAY' email as a result. 2) Offer (CF) Marlon Sicho for (MR) Peter Mencl AND (SP) Hung Cathey- 'Complete Trade' button will be activated. - see: ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/2New.JPG Player Ratings (none are considered low): (CF) Marlon Sicho ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/3aNew.JPG (MR) Peter Mencl ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/4New.JPG (SP) Hung Cathey ftp://ftp.sigames.com/ootp/game-save/dim13New/5New.JPG - Submitting (CF) Marlon Sicho for (MR) Peter Mencl straight up (without involving (SP) Hung Cathey) the trade was refused (got a 'NO WAY' email). But if I add (SP) Hung Cathey to the trade from the other team - the 'Complete Trade' button is activated and I can complete the trade. - For players to acquire, If I had added (SP) Hung Cathey first in the list, and then added (MR) Peter Mencl second - the 'Complete Trade' button remains activated and I have absolutely no way off knowing that I am ripping off the computer team. I only can realize this if I had the players swapped - (MR) Peter Mencl first and then added (SP) Hung Cathey - for players to acquire from the other team. - You can substitute the following players from the other team (in place of (MR) Peter Mencl), and repeat steps (1) and (2) above with the same flaw/results - this problem still exists: - (SP) B.Iller - (SS) I.Kectan - (LF) S.Hug Version: 2.0.2.50 PC/MAC: PC Commissioner Mode: OFF ** I really hope Markus reads this example to let him know it's not just happening with players with very low ratings (as he stated). This example shows that it happens with all players, regardless of ratings. This is a major flaw that I really hope can be corrected at some point. Last edited by dim13; 05-10-2007 at 10:34 AM.