Thanks for all your comments. Interesting to hear the varying viewpoints, perhaps more so given the team with the question are the Grays.
cbbl, I appreciate your take on this with the added detail. For what it's worth, IIRC, the pbp described the outfielder as overunning the ball and it got past him. In my mind's eye, this was a looper into right field and he simply misplayed it letting it get by.