Justafan, thank you so much for your help. Can I ask a favor though? If you have more of a cartoonish-style bat could you put that in instead (just so the styles match up)

? And wtih the Pilgrims and Thunder could you make the bats smaller (if it still looks good) so that the overall picture can be closer to being a sqaure?
It drives me nuts asking people to change something they've done out of kindness, but here I go.