OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post - Official Rolen/Cubby Player Rating Question Thread

tkirch · 07-13-2006, 01:08 PM

I'm just not seeing any love in here for Chris Capuano.

Ran a sim 10 times and his average ERA is 4.56 Wins=9 Quality Starts=6

Last year he won 18 games and was second in the league in quality starts. This year he has 10 wins already, 3.81 ERA, and leads the Majors in Quality starts. You can guarantee that Capuano will go out pitch 7 innings every time and give up 3 runs or less. He has right now 27 1/3 scoreless inning streak against the Cubs. Cubs hate him is that why he isn't getting the love.

Also the Brewer hitting coach is Butch Wynegar not Butch Smith. Minor change.

I'm a Brewer fan obviously and was watching their stats. Their win-loss seemed right on but Bill Hall's power numbers seem low. He is on pace for 35 this year. I see him more of a 20-25 homer guy.
JJ hardy is a darn good hitter and is not being portrayed that at all. In the second half last year he batted over .300 with some pop. And his defense is amazing.
Corey Koskie is a bit better than his ratings show, not a lot but I would say a 260-270 hitter with 20 homer pop.

You may have Corey Harts power numbers a bit high. He had power in minors but he is more a spray hitter with 15-20 homer power but a good average, fast as hell too.

Doug Davis is a consistent pitcher and a good number three his ERA we're popping around mid 5's in the sims he is a low to mid 4's.

This may seem trivial but coming from a small market club ot many people pay any attention to the Brewers except players like Fielder or Weeks. But they have some other good players, Carlos Lee is a machine and easily the best player on this team. Jenkins is a pathetic strikeout prone player who has no pop in his bat this year and Bill Hall can play 5 positions and play great defense. He can hit and in the clutch is easily one of the best brewers. You should watch him play defense and some of th eplays he makes are awesome.

My two cents take it for what it is worth.

07-13-2006, 01:08 PM	#152
tkirch Minors (Double A) Join Date: Jul 2002 Posts: 196	I'm just not seeing any love in here for Chris Capuano. Ran a sim 10 times and his average ERA is 4.56 Wins=9 Quality Starts=6 Last year he won 18 games and was second in the league in quality starts. This year he has 10 wins already, 3.81 ERA, and leads the Majors in Quality starts. You can guarantee that Capuano will go out pitch 7 innings every time and give up 3 runs or less. He has right now 27 1/3 scoreless inning streak against the Cubs. Cubs hate him is that why he isn't getting the love. Also the Brewer hitting coach is Butch Wynegar not Butch Smith. Minor change. I'm a Brewer fan obviously and was watching their stats. Their win-loss seemed right on but Bill Hall's power numbers seem low. He is on pace for 35 this year. I see him more of a 20-25 homer guy. JJ hardy is a darn good hitter and is not being portrayed that at all. In the second half last year he batted over .300 with some pop. And his defense is amazing. Corey Koskie is a bit better than his ratings show, not a lot but I would say a 260-270 hitter with 20 homer pop. You may have Corey Harts power numbers a bit high. He had power in minors but he is more a spray hitter with 15-20 homer power but a good average, fast as hell too. Doug Davis is a consistent pitcher and a good number three his ERA we're popping around mid 5's in the sims he is a low to mid 4's. This may seem trivial but coming from a small market club ot many people pay any attention to the Brewers except players like Fielder or Weeks. But they have some other good players, Carlos Lee is a machine and easily the best player on this team. Jenkins is a pathetic strikeout prone player who has no pop in his bat this year and Bill Hall can play 5 positions and play great defense. He can hit and in the clutch is easily one of the best brewers. You should watch him play defense and some of th eplays he makes are awesome. My two cents take it for what it is worth.