OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post - Official Rolen/Cubby Player Rating Question Thread

majesty95 · 07-06-2006, 05:11 PM

Putz...one season wonders do not deserve to be at the level of elite players who have done it for years. Same thing for Papelbon, although his minor league stats suggest he is the real deal. I do agree his stamina should be higher than a normal relievers and he should be rated better than Putz. Putz, I think, should be slightly above average and close to his potential since he's 29.

I think one of the main reasons people post things they think should be changed is this. Say you notice one or two of your guys rated below where you feel they really should be. Well, what if it is like that for a couple of guys per team you just don't know it because you're not as familiar with the other teams. While some may say that you shouldn't miss it then, others would say the roster set isnt very accurate if it misses that many players.

Obviously, I'm not saying that this set is like that, but people giving their thoughts shouldn't automatically be told to change it themselves. You should, hoever, give evidence of why you think the players should be rated higher. You never know who that next superstar is going to be and its always cool to have them develop into one in your sim before they do in real life do to some handy insider info.

07-06-2006, 05:11 PM	#81
majesty95 All Star Starter Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: San Antonio, TX Posts: 1,789	Putz...one season wonders do not deserve to be at the level of elite players who have done it for years. Same thing for Papelbon, although his minor league stats suggest he is the real deal. I do agree his stamina should be higher than a normal relievers and he should be rated better than Putz. Putz, I think, should be slightly above average and close to his potential since he's 29. I think one of the main reasons people post things they think should be changed is this. Say you notice one or two of your guys rated below where you feel they really should be. Well, what if it is like that for a couple of guys per team you just don't know it because you're not as familiar with the other teams. While some may say that you shouldn't miss it then, others would say the roster set isnt very accurate if it misses that many players. Obviously, I'm not saying that this set is like that, but people giving their thoughts shouldn't automatically be told to change it themselves. You should, hoever, give evidence of why you think the players should be rated higher. You never know who that next superstar is going to be and its always cool to have them develop into one in your sim before they do in real life do to some handy insider info. Last edited by majesty95; 07-06-2006 at 05:12 PM.