View Single Post
Old 04-02-2005, 11:49 PM   #659
cknox0723
All Star Starter
 
cknox0723's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: NJ
Posts: 1,957
Quote:
Originally Posted by johnny slick
Just as I do not believe that players should be credited for homeruns they did not hit, neither do I think that Hal Chase should be credited for cashing in on potential and athletic ability that he did not.
this is tangential, but that's what makes the world go round. john, i'm interested in the first half of that statement. do you also include folks like ted williams missing time due to war in that? how about someone like grove who was blocked in the "lesser" minor leagues for forces beyond his control? do you credit them for that or prefer to stick to major league statistics on record?

just genuinely (or maybe disingenuously ) curious.
__________________
Craig

the pale hose: year 1/hitchhiker's guide to.../wild thing, you make my heart sing/year 2/THE TRADE/making the playoffs
Quote:
Originally Posted by DAL 9000
Syllabus: In this class we will construct a lifelike semblance of a woman using nothing more than chert and pyrite. Students will sleep within her cold embrace each night, and, for extra credit, may produce a lengthy paper detailing how she is the only person who has ever understood them.
cknox0723 is offline   Reply With Quote