OOTP Developments Forums - View Single Post

Eugene Church · 03-09-2005, 05:50 PM

This may be the best set overall...all of them are very well done.

#1...Very fine logo in all respects...well done and even has a baseball...really captures the essence of "Cherokees".

#2...Well done...fine design, colors and font...however, imho it is too small...wish he had used more of the space available and made Charlotte lettering larger and maybe added a few other Indian elements.

#3...Nice logo...great idea for the face and hair on the baseball..but the hair doesn't stand out enough for me...maybe a war bonnet might have been better...colors need to be brighter and more eyecatching like #1, #5, #8, #10 and #11.

#4...Nice colors and font...but the design doesn't grab my attention...but it is technically well done.

#5...Very fine design, colors and font...like the arrows through "CC" and baseball a lot...like the font for "Charlotte" and "Cherokees"...but "CC" looks hand-drawn and might have been done better.

#6...Excellent logo in almost everything...the crossed arrows on the baseball is an excellent concept...really like the font and the placement of the lettering...but "Cherokees" need better contrast...it is hard for me to read...Techically excellent...but really needs brighter colors to standout like #1, #5, #8, #10, and #11.

#7...Excellent logo...really like the lettering placement and the arrows with the feathers...fine font...technically excellent...would have preferred brighter colors...not crazy about the greens.

#8...Excellent in all respects...really like the simplicity of it...fine Indian image...great colors and color coordination...like the feather extending out of the circle...and like the fact that he didn't cover any letters with the feather...imo one should never allow one element to obscure or clutter another element in the logo...this one and #10 are outstanding.

#9...Excellent in everything, but the colors...needs brighter colors...fine design and font...very nice touch with the feathers on the "C".

#10...Excellent in all respects...great colors...great design and great Indian figure...it made me think of a great Cherokee warrior...and the designer even added a red frame/border...I am partial to frames and borders...imho this one and #8 are the superior logos in this excellent set.

#11...Excellent in all respects...period...I might have preferred the arrowheads to be separated rather than place together...I thought it was a seven-pointed star at first...thanks to gubaru...I now understand why the designer did it this way.

#12...Nicely done...I like the Indian ponies on the sides...but the figure is hard to figure out what it is...at least for me...I think it is an Indian, but it is in a strange pose.

#13 Done well...Excellent Indian figure...would have liked more eyecatching colors...wish the war bonnet didn't run into the "Cherokees" lettering...and I always want the name of the city, too....sorry, just my taste...which is not universal.

Thanks to all of the designers for sharing their fine talents and creativity with us.

03-09-2005, 05:50 PM	#15
Eugene Church Hall Of Famer Join Date: Aug 2002 Posts: 35,958	This may be the best set overall...all of them are very well done. #1...Very fine logo in all respects...well done and even has a baseball...really captures the essence of "Cherokees". #2...Well done...fine design, colors and font...however, imho it is too small...wish he had used more of the space available and made Charlotte lettering larger and maybe added a few other Indian elements. #3...Nice logo...great idea for the face and hair on the baseball..but the hair doesn't stand out enough for me...maybe a war bonnet might have been better...colors need to be brighter and more eyecatching like #1, #5, #8, #10 and #11. #4...Nice colors and font...but the design doesn't grab my attention...but it is technically well done. #5...Very fine design, colors and font...like the arrows through "CC" and baseball a lot...like the font for "Charlotte" and "Cherokees"...but "CC" looks hand-drawn and might have been done better. #6...Excellent logo in almost everything...the crossed arrows on the baseball is an excellent concept...really like the font and the placement of the lettering...but "Cherokees" need better contrast...it is hard for me to read...Techically excellent...but really needs brighter colors to standout like #1, #5, #8, #10, and #11. #7...Excellent logo...really like the lettering placement and the arrows with the feathers...fine font...technically excellent...would have preferred brighter colors...not crazy about the greens. #8...Excellent in all respects...really like the simplicity of it...fine Indian image...great colors and color coordination...like the feather extending out of the circle...and like the fact that he didn't cover any letters with the feather...imo one should never allow one element to obscure or clutter another element in the logo...this one and #10 are outstanding. #9...Excellent in everything, but the colors...needs brighter colors...fine design and font...very nice touch with the feathers on the "C". #10...Excellent in all respects...great colors...great design and great Indian figure...it made me think of a great Cherokee warrior...and the designer even added a red frame/border...I am partial to frames and borders...imho this one and #8 are the superior logos in this excellent set. #11...Excellent in all respects...period...I might have preferred the arrowheads to be separated rather than place together...I thought it was a seven-pointed star at first...thanks to gubaru...I now understand why the designer did it this way. #12...Nicely done...I like the Indian ponies on the sides...but the figure is hard to figure out what it is...at least for me...I think it is an Indian, but it is in a strange pose. #13 Done well...Excellent Indian figure...would have liked more eyecatching colors...wish the war bonnet didn't run into the "Cherokees" lettering...and I always want the name of the city, too....sorry, just my taste...which is not universal. Thanks to all of the designers for sharing their fine talents and creativity with us.