The rarest cards in PT universe!
 

Hey guys,

here is the complete list of cards being pulled 10 times or less, as of January 28. The 1946 Ted Williams has NEVER been pulled yet... who is the first? :p

Category, Player, Team, Year, Value, Times pulled
Top WAR, LF Ted Williams, BOS, 1946 96 0
Legend, CL Lee Smith, CHC, PEAK 95 1
Legend, SP Mike Mussina, BAL, PEAK 96 1
Top WAR, 3B Al Rosen, CLE, 1953 96 1
Top WAR, LF Stan Musial, STL, 1948 97 1
Top WAR, SS Alex Rodriguez, SEA, 1996 97 1
Legend, SP Curt Schilling, BOS, PEAK 98 1
Top WAR, SS Cal Ripken Jr, BAL, 1991 96 2
Top WAR, SS Lou Boudreau, CLE, 1948 100 2
Top WAR, SS Rico Petrocelli, BOS, 1969 97 2
Legend, 3B Edgar Martinez, SEA, PEAK 99 3
Legend, RF Harold Baines, CWS, PEAK 89 3
Top WAR, 3B Ron Santo, CHC, 1967 96 3
Top WAR, CF Rickey Henderson, NYY, 1985 97 3
Legend, RF Billy L Williams, CHC, PEAK 92 4
Legend, SP Roy Halladay, TOR, PEAK 97 4
Top WAR, LF Barry Bonds, SF, 2001 97 4
Top WAR, 2B Joe Morgan, CIN, 1975 98 5
Top WAR, 2B Rogers Hornsby, STL, 1924 100 5
Top WAR, CF Mike Trout, LAA, 2016 96 5
Top WAR, CF Willie Mays, SF, 1965 97 5
Legend, C King Kelly, CHC, PEAK 98 6
Legend, CL Mariano Rivera, NYY, PEAK 100 6
Top WAR, CF Mickey Mantle, NYY, 1957 100 6
Top WAR, SP Hal Newhouser, DET, 1945 97 6
Top WAR, SP Pedro Martinez, BOS, 2000 97 6
Top WAR, SS Robin Yount, ML4, 1982 96 6
Record Breaker, CL Craig Kimbrel, ATL, 2012 96 7
Top WAR, RF Babe Ruth, NYY, 1923 99 7
Top WAR, SP Dazzy Vance, BRO, 1924 96 7
Top WAR, SP Steve Carlton, PHI, 1972 94 7
All-Star, SS Alan Trammell, DET, 1984 96 8
Legend, 2B Joe L Morgan, CIN, PEAK 93 8
Legend, C Yogi Berra, NYY, PEAK 92 8
Legend, LF Carl Yastrzemski, BOS, PEAK 97 8
Record Breaker, SP Dwight Gooden, NYM, 1985 97 8
Rookie Sensation, SP Hideo Nomo, LAD, 1995 93 8
Top WAR, 1B Lou Gehrig, NYY, 1927 100 8
Top WAR, CF Bryce Harper, WAS, 2015 96 8
Top WAR, SP Dolf Luque, CIN, 1923 95 8
Top WAR, SP Pete Alexander, CHC, 1920 93 8
Top WAR, SP Randy Johnson, ARI, 2002 93 8
Top WAR, SS Ernie Banks, CHC, 1959 96 8
All-Star, LF Alfonso Soriano, WAS, 2006 70 9
All-Star, SP Van Mungo, BRO, 1936 92 9
Legend, 3B Mike Schmidt, PHI, PEAK 95 9
Legend, SS Alex Rodriguez, NYY, PEAK 93 9
Record Breaker, CL Bruce Sutter, CHC, 1977 7 95 9
Top WAR, SP Zack Greinke, KC, 2009 96 9
Legend, 2B Rogers Hornsby, STL, PEAK 97 10
Legend, C Mickey Cochrane, PHA, PEAK 96 10
Legend, LF Babe Ruth, NYY, PEAK 96 10
Legend, LF Ed Delahanty, PHI, PEAK 92 10
Legend, SS Ernie Banks, CHC, PEAK 90 10
Legend, SS Honus Wagner, PIT, PEAK 96 10
Top WAR, SP Bob Feller, CLE, 1940 96 10
Top WAR, SP Dizzy Trout, DET, 1944 91 10
Top WAR, SP Greg Maddux, ATL, 1995 100 10
Top WAR, SP Sandy Koufax, LAD, 1963 95 10

Cheers,
Markus

I see that 96 Ripken or Perfect Boudreau card that I want isn't going to be around anytime soon

Rip more packs! ;)

Side note. There is a typo on the ARod card. It should be 1996, but the real issue is how he didn't win MVP that year. It's a joke Juan Gonzalez beat him in Homeruns and wasn't even close in any other offensive stat.

I was going to suggest adding MVP cards to PT but based on that alone I retract that thought.....




Name Tm Pts 1st Place Share WAR G AB R H HR RBI SB BB BA OBP SLG OPS
Juan Gonzalez TEX 290.0 11.0 74% 3.8 134 541 89 170 47 144 2 45 . 314 .368 .643 1.011

Alex Rodriguez SEA 287.0 10.0 73% 9.4 146 601 141 215 36 123 15 59 .358 .414 .631 1.045

Rare? Pfft. That's the lineup of every team I face in Perfect.

Cool, a list of cards I will never have. :p

If I could get 1985 Rickey, I would be sooooooo happy.

>Top WAR, SP Zack Greinke, KC, 2009 96 9

I actually pulled one, now I wish I didn't sell it.

Thanks for posting the list as it is nice to see what is out there.

That Joe L Morgan has been in the auction house tempting me as a 2B bat upgrade, but man that defense is terrible. Especially since the other 2 Diamond Morgans are high-end defenders.

Hey, I'm one of the 8 who has pulled that Yogi! That explains why I never see it in the AH.

Increase the drop rate for Challenge Mode!:o

Great post. This is something I've wondered about for a while.

Not gonna lie, tempted to sell off my team just to try and get one of these guys. Or a perfect Pedro

Did you restrict the list to Diamonds & Perfects? There are some historic golds that that I've seen in the auction house for the first time.

I have that Big Ed Delahanty card that has only been pulled 10 times.

That All Star Soriano is only a 70, apparently.

The Baines is also a gold. It's more that Golds are just so much more common than Diamonds that they've all been pulled a ton of times. Chris didn't give us all the stats, but the historical golds have probably all been pulled 40+ times, other than the post-release content.

How about Dusty Rhodes 91 overall Unsung Hero? I have never seen that card in any of my leagues or on the AH. I have ratings on a spreadsheet and have every card (basic ratings not splits) except him or 100 Rogers Hornsby. Anyway you can post their ratings???

I don't know if it was your card that I bought, but if it makes you feel any better, 1985 Rickey is batting .184 and posting a 63 OPS+ so far for me, in 114 plate appearances. But this is where I have to admit that we play in a pitchers' park with all the factors at the minimum. Still, we do go on the road sometimes...

I'm excited to own Rickey, although he has a significant platoon split. He'll be part of a RF platoon.

With the purchase of 1985 Rickey Henderson, I now own three of these cards. I've got 2015 Bryce Harper playing RF and 1920 Pete Alexander as the long guy in my pen. When I acquired the latter two, I had no idea that they were special. It's fun to learn that!

Truth
 

ME 2


I lost 100+ games again this year. I don't belong anywhere hear Perfect Leagues. 1st off...I don't even have a 100 rated card & the highest card Nolan Arenado 90 something hits like Edgar Renteria every year. Useless Card,,,,and I got the one of the Harold Baines card...not a very good card in Perfect League. Haven't used in anywhere else....I much prefer playing in the lower leagues where the 60-70 rated cards preform well and bring back my awesome memories from youth
BB
Chicago Black Sox....btw...My season ended with getting a PERFECT GAME pitched against me in game 161 & 1 HIT in game 162, but was a solo homerun by Javier Lopez in 8th....