Want to bump this idea. I've got a few suggestions about Montreal ratings that I think would be better in a thread more specific to player ratings..

Gary Roberts is drastically underrated. I've yet to see him play on Carolina or Toronto. In Toronto the guy was a monster in the playoffs going to the dirty places to get the goals and create scoring chances...although he paid the price as he was injured a lot. I always believed the day the Leafs lost Roberts and Nieuwendyk was the big downfall of the leafs that had only ended this past year in making the playoffs.

Gary Roberts ability should be a 7.5 at least when he is on the leafs and a guy who turns it up in the playoffs.

The abbreviation for the Hamilton Bulldogs should be HAM not HAB, (as appropriate as that would be...)